Winners.. HumoDEVA 2015



The Winners of HumoDEVA 2015 or THE FULL TRANSPARENCY..


Cuma 03.07.2015 Cartoon Colors
From the 1523 works received at first, 1113 preselected were exhibited on this gallery, HumoDEVA 2015. This first trial was performed by Horia CRISAN.
We announced the jury composition, all of the jurors being cartoonists:
Borislav STANKOVIC, Serbia, cartoonist, President of the Jury
Julian PENA-PAI, Romania, cartoonist, jury member
Bogdan PETRY, Romania, cartoonist, jury member
Liviu STANILA, Romania, cartoonist, jury member
Horia CRISAN, Romanian, cartoonist, jury member 
They worked at home, no meetings or discussions among them, so they have made
their own choice and only by personal opinion.
Initially, each juror has the right to choose as many works he considered good, among the 1113 from the public gallery. After putting together all those options, we obtained the first 241 pre selected for awards discussion. 
From the 241 cartoons, each jury member has to select his top 20 drawings, independently, each work receiving 1 vote (1 point). And the result was a restraint gallery of 79 finalists
Those finalists were presented to the public on BestCARTOONS.net and cartoonists of the world were invited to pronnounce about it, in a 10 days time, concerning possible fraude, plagiarism and/or similarities.
We received 7 works with similarity problems, every one of them was withdrawn from the prize discussion. Click here.
The way of voting of each jury member is presented in this table. As you can see, the selected works received votes from 1, 2 or 3 jurors (1, 2 or 3 points). 
The prize giving criterias are explained on the ''J'' column of our table of contents .

So, the Prizes of HumoDEVA 2015 are:

GOLD PRIZE
500$, Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net 
Oleg GUTSOL, Ukraine
SILVER PRIZE, 
ex aequo
400$, Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Galym BORANBAYEV, Kazakhstan (200 $)
Constantin CIOSU, Romania (200 $)
BRONZE PRIZE,
ex aequo
300$, Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Pavel MATUSKA, Czech Republic (150 $)
Constantin PAVEL, Romania (150 $)
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Toso BORKOVICH, Serbia
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Mehdi AZIZI, Iran
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Lubomir MIHAILOV, Bulgaria
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
S. SANTIAGU, Portugal
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
B. V. PANDURANGA, India
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Sergii RIABOKON, Ukraine
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Alexander DUBOVSKY, Ukraine
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Seyran CAFERLI, Azerbaijan
  EXCELLENCY
Special Honor Diploma and a Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.net
Valeriy CHMYRIOV, Ukraine

The Special Prize of The Jury
Special Honor Diploma
Klaus PITTER, Austria

The Special Prize for Portrait
Special Honor Diploma
Mario MAGNATTI, Italy

The Special Prize of CRISAN Publishing House
Special Honor Diploma
Dragutin KOVACEVIC, Croatia

The Special Prize of CRISAN Publishing House
Special Honor Diploma
Fernando PICA, Colombia

The Special Prize of CRISAN Publishing House
Special Honor Diploma
Raed KHALIL, Syria

The Special Diploma
Special Honor Diploma
Sergey ERMILOV, Russia

The Special Prize of ''ACCES'' Association
Special Honor Diploma
Mojtaba HEIDARPANAH, Iran

The Special Prize of ''ACCES'' Association
Special Honor Diploma
Luc DESCHEEMAEKER, Belgium

The Special Prize of Deva Culture Center
Special Honor Diploma
Nicolae LENGHER, Romania

The Special Prize of Deva Culture Center
Special Honor Diploma
Gabi RUSU, Romania

So we tried, as you have seen on these pages, to make the things in TOTAL TRANSPARENCY. We think that we have succeeded and also we hope that our transparency example will be followed by a lot of juries in several cartoon contests around the world. 
The Jury, Deva, 1.07.2015
- Source/Best Cartoons.net
-Rules


Gold Prize
500$, Special Honor Diploma and
a Personal Gallery onBestCARTOONS.net 
Oleg GUTSOL
Ukraine

Special Honor Diploma anda Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.netAlexander DUBOVSKYUkraine

The Special Prize of ''ACCES'' Association
Special Honor Diploma
Mojtaba HEIDARPANAH
Iran

Special Honor Diploma anda Personal Gallery on BestCARTOONS.netValeriy CHMYRIOVUkraine

Special Honor Diploma anda Personal Gallery on 
BestCARTOONS.net
Seyran CAFERLI
Azerbaijan